Top Ice Cream Spots on Cape Cod for Summer 2024

Top Ice Cream Spots on Cape Cod for Summer 2024

Cape Cod is a summer paradise known for its stunning beaches, charming towns, and a plethora of delicious ice cream shops. Whether you’re looking for a classic cone, a sundae, or a unique frozen treat, the Cape has something to satisfy every sweet tooth. Here’s a guide to the best ice cream spots on Cape Cod for your summer 2024 adventures.

1. Four Seas Ice Cream (Centerville)

Established in 1934, Four Seas Ice Cream is one of the oldest and most beloved ice cream parlors on Cape Cod. Known for its rich, creamy texture and classic flavors, this spot is a must-visit. Favorites include the fresh peach, homemade black raspberry, and their famous lemon crisp. Located in a historic building, Four Seas offers a nostalgic experience that will delight ice cream lovers of all ages.

2. Sundae School (Dennisport, Harwich Port, East Orleans)

Sundae School has been serving up delicious homemade ice cream since 1976. With three locations on the Cape, it's easy to find one nearby. Their ice cream is made on-site and offers a variety of flavors, from classic vanilla and chocolate to unique creations like ginger and cranberry sherbet. Sundae School is also famous for their sundaes, topped with fresh whipped cream and hot fudge.

3. Katie’s Homemade Ice Cream (Hyannis)

Katie’s Homemade Ice Cream, located on Main Street in Hyannis, is known for its wide variety of flavors and high-quality ingredients. Their ice cream is made in small batches, ensuring freshness and a rich, creamy texture. Popular flavors include Cape Cod Sand (a mix of vanilla, Oreo, and chocolate chips) and blueberry pie. Katie’s also offers dairy-free and vegan options, making it a great choice for everyone.

4. Ice Cream Smuggler (Dennis)

Ice Cream Smuggler has been a staple in Dennis since 1979. This family-owned shop offers a variety of homemade ice creams, with popular flavors like Oreo, butter crunch, and their award-winning peppermint stick. The Smuggler's thick, creamy ice cream and generous portions make it a favorite among locals and visitors alike.

5. Ben & Bill’s Chocolate Emporium (Falmouth)

Ben & Bill’s Chocolate Emporium in Falmouth offers a delightful combination of homemade ice cream and gourmet chocolates. Their extensive menu includes classic flavors as well as unique options like lobster ice cream, which contains real lobster pieces. With its charming atmosphere and variety of treats, Ben & Bill’s is a must-visit spot on the Cape.

6. The Local Scoop (Orleans)

The Local Scoop is a unique ice cream shop in Orleans that focuses on local and organic ingredients. They offer a rotating selection of flavors, ensuring that there's always something new to try. In addition to traditional ice cream, The Local Scoop features frozen yogurt, sorbet, and a DIY toppings bar. This spot is perfect for those looking to customize their ice cream experience.

7. The Ice Cream Café (Orleans)

Located in the heart of Orleans, The Ice Cream Café is known for its creative flavors and use of natural ingredients. They offer an array of options, including dairy-free and vegan ice cream. Popular choices include salted caramel, chocolate peanut butter, and their signature "Mudslide" (coffee ice cream with fudge swirl and Oreos). The cozy café setting makes it a perfect spot to enjoy a sweet treat.

8. Schoolhouse Ice Cream (Harwich Port)

Schoolhouse Ice Cream, located in Harwich Port, offers a wide variety of homemade flavors and generous portions. The charming, schoolhouse-themed setting adds to the appeal. Favorites include banana Oreo, espresso bean, and their refreshing fruit sorbets. This family-friendly spot is perfect for a summer afternoon treat.

9. Polar Cave Ice Cream Parlour (Mashpee)

Polar Cave Ice Cream Parlour in Mashpee is known for its homemade ice cream and fun, polar-themed décor. The shop offers a wide range of flavors, including classics and creative options like "Shark's Tooth" (black raspberry with chocolate chips) and "Monkey Business" (banana ice cream with fudge swirl and walnuts). Their hand-dipped waffle cones are a must-try.

10. Sweet Carolines Ice Cream (Sandwich)

Sweet Carolines Ice Cream in Sandwich offers a delightful variety of homemade flavors in a charming, old-fashioned setting. Their menu includes options like Snickers, pistachio, and coconut almond joy. Sweet Carolines also offers soft serve, frozen yogurt, and a variety of toppings, making it a great spot for the whole family.


Cape Cod's ice cream scene is as diverse and delightful as its scenic beaches and quaint towns. From historic parlors to innovative spots using local ingredients, there's something for every ice cream lover on the Cape. Be sure to visit these top ice cream destinations this summer and indulge in the sweet flavors of Cape Cod. Whether you're craving a classic cone or a unique frozen treat, these spots promise to deliver a delicious experience that will make your summer unforgettable.

Work With Us

We would be honored to represent you in your real estate transaction. We offer white glove service to every client and can't wait to share our local expertise and market knowledge with you. Please reach out today!